It's that time of year, when everyone unites with loved ones to share a meal featuring that beloved bird, the turkey, which otherwise goes unnoticed for the rest of the year, with the exception of Christmas. And like anything else, there are as many different ways of preparing turkey and its fixin's as there are people, so the options really are endless.
I will admit that I won't be cooking this year. Instead, I'll be feasting on a supermarket turkey meal. Don't judge, just pray for me! And even though I won't be in the kitchen this year, I did want to pass on some pearls of wisdom about the main dish. So let's get back to the "if I were cooking" scenario...
Over the years, many a cookbook and holiday issued magazine have fine tuned certain techniques for creating a tastier bird. For one, you should try organic or even an heirloom variety if you can find it. Anyone who has ever tasted organic chicken will tell you how much more chicken-y it tastes compared to its drugged up cousin. Heirloom turkey are much like tomatoes or anything else heirloom, they are breeds that got left behind in the age of supermarket standardization. In a strange twist of fate, as the average American gets larger, they continually seek leaner (read: dry & flavorless) meats. (I guess that alone will keep them healthy, right???) As a result, farmers have been cross-breeding chicken & turkey to create ones with very large breasts (LA style), just to please all those lean white meat lovers. Heirloom breeds will provide more variety in terms of white to dark meat ratios and flavors.
Whichever bird you get, I highly recommend brining your turkey. For those of you who aren't familiar with the technique, it is a salt-sugar-spice-water solution into which you soak your meat (this works well for our very lean American pork too). It really does add moisture and flavor.
Since chicken and turkey are so darn similar, I think we can apply many of our tried-and-true chicken techniques to turkey as well. I have never basted a roasted chicken, so why bother with turkey? If you think about it, the liquid will just roll right off the skin and into the pan. Not to mention the oven temperature will drop from all that time you spent basting with the oven door open. And isn't part of the objective to obtain crispy skin? Water or juice will just make it soggy. A little fat (butter or oil) massaged into the skin, on the other hand, will expedite the cripsing process. If you really want to flavor the meat, you should stuff seasonings under the skin, so it lubricates and seasons the meat as it melts and cooks. A nice herbed butter is perfect for this task! I do this all the time for my roasted chicken.
And lastly, the stuffing...where to begin??? I know many of you are traditionalist who like to stuff the turkey, only to remove it again once it is cooked because your mother did it that way and so did her mother, and so forth. But to me it's like setting the table with dishes, only to collect all the dishes again, so you can plate the food in the kitchen. It just doesn't make sense. But more importantly, once your stuffing has touched the raw bird, it potentially has salmonella and other bird cooties, and now needs to be cooked to a high enough temp to kill all contaminants. To get the inside of the turkey hot enough, you can image how much hotter the meat part of the turkey will need to be. To make sure we're all on the same page, the hotter the meat, the more cooked it is. The more cooked it is, the dryer and tougher it becomes. Any questions? So, the moral of the story is to cook your stuffing seperately, so it will produce a moister bird. Feel free to use the turkey neck and giblets in your stuffing, though, to give it more flavor. If you are really ambitious, a homemade turkey stock would help too.
I'm sorry I don't have oodles of pictures or recipes for you this time. I do think I have prepared you well to make a delicious main dish. I recommend keeping the menu simple. I know I usually don't, but I'm a trained professional, and you shouldn't try what I do at home. :-) All you need is some dip and nuts for people to nibble on when they arrive. Keep side dishes to a minimum, as too many won't even fit neatly on the plate anyways. You really only need stuffing (I like sausage in mine), a potato (mashed), a veggie (green bean), a sweet potato (if you must), gravy and cranberry sauce. Find a good bakery or ask someone to bring dessert. This is an occassion to create a memorable holiday, not necessarily a four-star restaurant quality meal. And if you're lucky, you'll get to enjoy it as well.
Below is the summarized recipe Alton Brown did for Bon Appetit a few years ago. Although I find Alton hard to watch on tv because he's a little too hokey for my taste, I do think his lessons and methods are quite good. Read it now, so you can procure all the necessary tools and items in time for the big feast.
Brined Roasted Turkey
Bon Appetit Nov. 2003
Serves 12
18 lb. Frozen Turkey
For the Brine:
Hot Tap Water
2/3 cup Sugar
1 lb. Salt
I will admit that I won't be cooking this year. Instead, I'll be feasting on a supermarket turkey meal. Don't judge, just pray for me! And even though I won't be in the kitchen this year, I did want to pass on some pearls of wisdom about the main dish. So let's get back to the "if I were cooking" scenario...
Over the years, many a cookbook and holiday issued magazine have fine tuned certain techniques for creating a tastier bird. For one, you should try organic or even an heirloom variety if you can find it. Anyone who has ever tasted organic chicken will tell you how much more chicken-y it tastes compared to its drugged up cousin. Heirloom turkey are much like tomatoes or anything else heirloom, they are breeds that got left behind in the age of supermarket standardization. In a strange twist of fate, as the average American gets larger, they continually seek leaner (read: dry & flavorless) meats. (I guess that alone will keep them healthy, right???) As a result, farmers have been cross-breeding chicken & turkey to create ones with very large breasts (LA style), just to please all those lean white meat lovers. Heirloom breeds will provide more variety in terms of white to dark meat ratios and flavors.
Whichever bird you get, I highly recommend brining your turkey. For those of you who aren't familiar with the technique, it is a salt-sugar-spice-water solution into which you soak your meat (this works well for our very lean American pork too). It really does add moisture and flavor.
Since chicken and turkey are so darn similar, I think we can apply many of our tried-and-true chicken techniques to turkey as well. I have never basted a roasted chicken, so why bother with turkey? If you think about it, the liquid will just roll right off the skin and into the pan. Not to mention the oven temperature will drop from all that time you spent basting with the oven door open. And isn't part of the objective to obtain crispy skin? Water or juice will just make it soggy. A little fat (butter or oil) massaged into the skin, on the other hand, will expedite the cripsing process. If you really want to flavor the meat, you should stuff seasonings under the skin, so it lubricates and seasons the meat as it melts and cooks. A nice herbed butter is perfect for this task! I do this all the time for my roasted chicken.
And lastly, the stuffing...where to begin??? I know many of you are traditionalist who like to stuff the turkey, only to remove it again once it is cooked because your mother did it that way and so did her mother, and so forth. But to me it's like setting the table with dishes, only to collect all the dishes again, so you can plate the food in the kitchen. It just doesn't make sense. But more importantly, once your stuffing has touched the raw bird, it potentially has salmonella and other bird cooties, and now needs to be cooked to a high enough temp to kill all contaminants. To get the inside of the turkey hot enough, you can image how much hotter the meat part of the turkey will need to be. To make sure we're all on the same page, the hotter the meat, the more cooked it is. The more cooked it is, the dryer and tougher it becomes. Any questions? So, the moral of the story is to cook your stuffing seperately, so it will produce a moister bird. Feel free to use the turkey neck and giblets in your stuffing, though, to give it more flavor. If you are really ambitious, a homemade turkey stock would help too.
I'm sorry I don't have oodles of pictures or recipes for you this time. I do think I have prepared you well to make a delicious main dish. I recommend keeping the menu simple. I know I usually don't, but I'm a trained professional, and you shouldn't try what I do at home. :-) All you need is some dip and nuts for people to nibble on when they arrive. Keep side dishes to a minimum, as too many won't even fit neatly on the plate anyways. You really only need stuffing (I like sausage in mine), a potato (mashed), a veggie (green bean), a sweet potato (if you must), gravy and cranberry sauce. Find a good bakery or ask someone to bring dessert. This is an occassion to create a memorable holiday, not necessarily a four-star restaurant quality meal. And if you're lucky, you'll get to enjoy it as well.
Below is the summarized recipe Alton Brown did for Bon Appetit a few years ago. Although I find Alton hard to watch on tv because he's a little too hokey for my taste, I do think his lessons and methods are quite good. Read it now, so you can procure all the necessary tools and items in time for the big feast.
Brined Roasted Turkey
Bon Appetit Nov. 2003
Serves 12
18 lb. Frozen Turkey
For the Brine:
Hot Tap Water
2/3 cup Sugar
1 lb. Salt
8 lb. Ice
16 cups (128 oz) Veggie Broth
For the Bird:
Fresh Herbs
Fresh Herbs
1 Onion, roughly chopped
2 Celery Stalks, roughly chopped
2 Large Carrots, roughly chopped
2 Large Carrots, roughly chopped
½ stick of Butter
Quick - Thawing the Turkey: Place the wrapped bird in a 5-gallon cooler with a drain spout. Place the cooler in the bathtub and cover the turkey with cold water. Drain and replace the water every 2-3 hours until it has thawed (8-10 hrs).
Slow – Thawing the Turkey: Place the bird in a cooler with about an inch of ice in the bottom. Park it in a cool place, and the bird will be workable in about four days. Add more ice if the cooler’s temp >40 degrees.
To Brine: In a clean cooler, pour in the hot tap water, the sugar and salt. Stir to dissolve. Then stir in the ice and broth. Place the cleaned turkey in the brine. If the turkey floats, fill 1-gallon resealable plastic bags with water and place it on top. Set in a cool place for 8-12 hours, turning over once if possible. *Be sure to keep brine below 40 degrees, by adding ice packs if necessary.
Cooking the Bird: Remove one rack, and place the other on the second to lowest position. Preheat oven to 500 degrees. Remove turkey from the brine, rinse and pat dry. Loosely pack the turkey cavity with the above herbs and veggies. Place turkey breast side up on a V-shaped raosting rack in a roasting pan.
Cut a piece of foil that when folded in half is big enough to cover the turkey’s breast. Lay this onto the breast, shiny side up, and mold it into the breastplate. Remove it, lube the underside with non-stick vegetable oil spray, and set aside. Rub the butter into the turkey.
Put turkey in the oven for 30 minutes, or until nicely browned. Remove the bird and apply the foil breast plate. Insert the thermometer’s probe directly through the foil and into the deepest part of the breast. Reduce oven temp to 350 degrees. Return turkey to the oven, and set thermometer probe to go off at 161 degrees (about 2 – 2½ hours).
Remove turkey from oven, and let rest, covered, for about ½ hour.





